A boat and the song that made it immortal

Posted

Last spring, Connie and I traveled to West Hartford, Conn., to spend time with our son, daughter-in-law, and grandson: Ethan, Hillary, and Remy. To say that Hillary is an avid reader would be an insult.

A better word to describe her reading would be voracious. She is definitely a bibliophile. Every room in their house has a bookshelf full of books. Well, not the bathroom, laundry room, or kitchen.

You get the idea.

Over the years, as we have visited them, it’s not unusual to stop into a bookstore. We have been to bookstores with them in every place they have lived, including Madison, Wisc. and South Bend, Ind.

So it was not a surprise when they took us to a small local book haven. After spending around 40 minutes perusing the titles on the shelves, Hillary and Connie had found a couple of titles. They also had selected some books for Remy to enjoy.

I, on the other hand, was disappointed. For some reason, there didn’t appear to be a history section. Then as we were heading out the door, there it was — a shelf of history books. One book caught my eye. So I pulled out my credit card again to purchase “The Gales of November, the Untold Story of the Edmund Fitzgerald,” by John U. Bacon.

Nov. 10 was the 51st Anniversary of the sinking of the Mighty Fitz on Lake Superior. Listed as one of the world’s most famous shipwrecks, the Fitzgerald was immortalized by Gordon Lightfoot’s song, “The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald.”

I know the words by heart, as do many people my age. I had to know more. The author does not disappoint.

Bacon starts by describing the immense size of the Great Lakes, which hold 20 percent of the world’s fresh water. “If you could empty the Great Lakes over North and South America, you would flood the land in a foot of standing water.” The lakes can also be more dangerous than the ocean. Freshwater in the lakes—as opposed to saltwater—creates larger and more frequent waves, up to 50 feet tall. This led to at least 6,000 ships sinking on the Great Lakes between 1875 and 1975. The Fitzgerald was the last.

Next, Bacon set the stage by covering the iron range in northern Wisconsin, and ships were needed to transport ore to the factories in Detroit and Cleveland. Without this, American industry could not have produced the war machines that enabled America to win World War II. Approximately 50 million tons of iron ore were transported across the Great Lakes in 1975.

After that, the author describes the construction of the SS Edmund Fitzgerald as the best and most luxurious ship on the Great Lakes from keel laying until its June 7, 1958 launch.

Twenty-nine sailors lost their lives on Nov. 10, 1975, when the Fitzgerald sank without warning. Bacon introduces the reader to each of those men and their jobs on the iron ore boat. Two were 63 years old, including Captain Ernest McSorley, who was on his last voyage before retirement.

Bruce Hudson, 22, was just starting his career as a deckhand on the Fritz. He played trombone in high school and was an Eagle Scout. Hudson owned a 1974 Dodge Challenger. He died never getting to see the birth of his daughter, Heather.

After thousands of pages of government reports and more than one expedition to the sunken vessel, the circumstances of the wreck remain unsolved. As Hudson’s mother, Ruth said, “Only thirty know what happened: twenty-nine men, and God.”

That brings us to Lightfoot’s ballad, without which the wreck of the Fitzgerald may not be known outside the Great Lakes region.

Considered one of Canada’s greatest songwriters, Lightfoot wrote “The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald” after reading an Associated Press article by Harry Atkins the day after the wreck and a piece in Newsweek.

At first, he was unsure of the song. According to Bacon, Lightfood “feared being inaccurate, corny, or worse, appearing to exploit a tragedy for profit.”

In the spring of 1976, Lightfoot and his band were in the studio working on their next album, Summertime Dream. After the group had cut ten songs with a day and a half of studio rental left, Lightfoot was finally talked into trying the song. 

Turns out the song everyone hears on the radio was not only the first take in the studio, but it was also the first time the band ever played the ballad, a song with no refrain.

Lightfoot, who died on May 1, 2023, became close friends with “the wives, the sons and the daughters,” and appeared at many of the anniversary memorial services.

The Fitzgerald lives on in song.