St. James utility board no longer needs council approval for contracts, purchases

• New ordinance shifts utility oversight back to board

By Connor Todd, Staff Writer
Posted 11/17/26

The St. James City Council voted Nov. 10 to pass an ordinance that gives the St. James Utility Board direct decision-making power and oversight of its own operations.

Newly passed Ordinance …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

E-mail
Password
Log in

St. James utility board no longer needs council approval for contracts, purchases

• New ordinance shifts utility oversight back to board

Posted

The St. James City Council voted Nov. 10 to pass an ordinance that gives the St. James Utility Board direct decision-making power and oversight of its own operations.

Newly passed Ordinance 26-1332 repeals section 700.085 of the city code, which required that all projects, plans, budgets, expenditures and contracts of the utility board be subject to the review and approval of the city council. The 6-1 vote by city council members approved the measure. Ward 2 Councilman Mark Gray was the sole “no” vote with  “yes” votes from Ward 1 Councilor David Bond, Ward 3 councilors Margaret Roberts and Ryan Miller, Ward 4 councilors Steve Hutchcraft and Marcie Wilson, and Ward 2 Councilman William Dunkus.

The St. James Municipal Utilities Board is made up of four-members who are appointed by the mayor and approved by the council. The board is responsible for managing the operations of the St. James Municipal Utilities service. Currently, the board is chaired by Stephanie Hayes, with Justin Hughes, Carl Redburn and Josh Hitch serving as members.

Going forward, the utility board will no longer require the council’s approval for purchases, as long as it adheres to the city’s procurement code. It will also be able to enter into contracts without approval from the council members. Future utility board contracts will be signed by the board itself instead of the mayor.

The utility board is still required under the city code to submit monthly reports to members of the St. James City Council. The board’s financial records will remain available for inspection by the city council’s finance committee.

The city council will still remain in control of the utility department’s budget, as required by Missouri state statute, and will continue to hear the utility board’s recommendations on how the department’s money should be budgeted, with all budget adjustments subject to the council’s approval. The council will also retain the final say on utility rates for all five of the city’s utilities.

The requirement that the utility board seeks approval from the council on most of its actions is only three years old. In November 2023, the St. James City Council passed Ordinance 23-1252, which added the now-repealed section 700.085 to the municipal code, making the city council’s total oversight of the utility board an outlier in its 79-year history.

According to City Administrator Leeann DeMouche, returning to the old status quo will have certain benefits for both the utility board and city council.

“The benefit of this is that they can become more focused on their utility operations. They can see a much greater financial oversight of the utilities. They can do more long-term planning. More informed decision-making, greater accountability,” DeMouche said. “And there’s less political influence over utility decisions doing this.”

She added that repealing section 700.085 would also have certain drawbacks, such as “a little less involvement by the elected officials, and also reduced coordination” between the utility board and city council.

The ordinance would empower the utilities department to get more work done quicker, according to DeMouche.

“It gives Lyle (Thomas, public works director) and I the ability to move faster on things. It allows us to focus more on utilities. The council is taking care of the city as a whole. This lets us focus more on the five utilities,” DeMouche said.

The ordinance was met with mixed, but majority, support from city council members.

Roberts said city business functioned better when the utility board had greater control over its own operations.

“What we’re trying to do tonight is how (the utility board) always did business and it worked well. We just need to go back. I think we need to give the utility board back their power,” Roberts said.

Dunkus, who ultimately voted in favor of the measure, expressed hesitant support.

“I look at the change, and I don’t have an objection to it,” Dunkus said. He added that the utility board seeking approval from the council on contracts and purchases “as a practical matter, has never really caused a problem. I think the board and the council work very well together now. That hasn’t always been the case.”

Gray, who cast the only dissenting vote, said he believes keeping the utility board’s actions under the direct oversight of the city council helps depoliticize the board’s functions and keeps accountability for the board’s actions with the council.

“You guys keep saying the political aspect is a bad thing. That’s the check that keeps us honest and keeps us doing what the public wants,” Gray said. “When you boil it down, the buck stops here. It doesn’t matter what (the utility board) decides, we’re gonna get blamed for it.”

St. James Mayor Rick Krawiecki endorsed the ordinance and said that less direct oversight from the city council on spending would allow the utility board to better execute its functions.

“If you have boards that don’t have a reason to meet, then what’s the reason for the board? I don’t want to get too far from the board,” Krawiecki said. “As long as the council can continue to work together hand-in-hand, I don’t think there’s a problem.”